Gloom and misery begone? Statistics gets a major makeover from a student-professor team

It is hard to teach statistics.

鈥淚t’s hard to learn, too,鈥 says psychology major Margaret Foster 鈥15 of York, Maine.

It’s a staple of the social sciences, yet learning stats has bedeviled generations of college students. At 乐播传媒, professors have tried to do something about it.

In the 1970s, 乐播传媒 psychologist Drake Bradley responded to the call to improve the teaching of statistics by using an innovative tool 鈥 the computer 鈥 to teach the ins and outs of data sets. He published a paper on it: “An interactive data-generating and answer-correcting system for problems in statistics.”

Today, Professor of Psychology Amy Douglass is using her own innovative strategy.

Professor of Psychology gathers her six-student team at the start of Short Term. Their goal: to transform how statistics is taught at 乐播传媒. (Phyllis Graber Jensen/乐播传媒 College)

Professor of Psychology Amy Douglass gathers her six-student team at the start of Short Term. Their goal: to transform how statistics is taught at 乐播传媒. (Phyllis Graber Jensen/乐播传媒 College)

Despite tweaks to the 乐播传媒 statistics course over the years, Douglass says that many students still have a hard time.

鈥淚f the course is ever going to appeal to students who are less comfortable with statistics, I need to understand the student experience,鈥 she says.

So Douglass took advantage of a distinctive new 乐播传媒 program offered this Short Term.

“We’re all about a continuous process of renewal.”

Called “Innovative Pedagogy / Course (Re)Design,” the program gives faculty the time and support (in this case, 乐播传媒 students) to rework an existing course or create a new one.

It’s highly unusual in American higher education: On a wide scale, 乐播传媒 is giving students the lead in improving how college courses are designed, deployed and taught.

Douglass enlisted six students, including Foster, to improve the 乐播传媒 statistics course, Psychology 218, and theirs was one of five Short Term courses whose goal was either to create a new course or improve an old one.

For the college, the course redesign program means that “we’re all about a continuous process of renewal,” says President Clayton Spencer. The new and revised courses “create new oxygen for the curriculum.”

鈥淚f the course is ever going to appeal to students who are less comfortable with statistics, I need to understand the student experience,鈥 says Professor of Psychology Amy Douglas. (Phyllis Graber Jensen/乐播传媒 College)

鈥淚f the course is ever going to appeal to students who are less comfortable with statistics, I need to understand the student experience,鈥 says Professor of Psychology Amy Douglass. (Phyllis Graber Jensen/乐播传媒 College)

This spring, “Team Douglass” comprised Foster, Afifa Avril 鈥15 of Decatur, Ga., Kelsey Berry 鈥15 of Hollis, N.H., Eleanor Hough 鈥16 of Summit, N.J., Patrece Joseph 鈥14 of Mattapan, Mass., and Nina Tupper 鈥14 of Kennebunk, Maine.

They did their work by reviewing current best practices, reading literature and doing a survey of students who had taken statistics.

Meeting four days a week with Douglass, the students also spent time outside class on various projects, from evaluating the effectiveness of quizzes to looking at how papers should be assigned.

Among other things, they learned from the survey that not one of 50 students surveyed felt that the textbook was at all helpful. On the other hand, every student said the weekly review sessions offered by Brian Pfohl, the department’s assistant in instruction, were 鈥渧ery helpful.鈥

By next winter, students who take statistics 鈥 required for the 70 or so majors who graduate in psychology or neuroscience each year 鈥 will experience a revised course that has student fingerprints all over it.

Here’s a general idea of how the course was formerly structured:

  • The class met three times a week
  • Weekly quiz on Mondays
  • Optional weekly review session on Friday afternoon
  • Four papers, known as 鈥渄emonstration reports鈥
  • Cumulative final exam

And here’s an overview of the changes coming:

We don’t need no stinkin’ texbooks!

Much maligned by students for being dense and redundant, the statistics textbook is now gone from the syllabus. (At the very least, it will save students $130!)

Watch and learn

Next year, students will be asked to watch videos outside of class to help them master 鈥渉and calculations.鈥 That’s the ability to do rough statistics calculations on your own.

“Being able to do hand calculations helps students understand what’s happening in the statistics software,” explains Patrece Joseph.

Hand calculations are lengthy and complicated. “Because students vary in how quickly they master them, the videos allow students to move at their own pace outside of class,” Douglass says.

More exams?

Instead of just one exam, the final, students will take three additional exams within the semester, each one testing students on material in one of the prior units.

True, adding exams increases the workload. 鈥淏ut we feel students need cumulative test experience before they take the final,鈥 says Nina Tupper.

Nina Tupper '14 of Kennebunk, Maine. (Phyllis Graber Jensen/乐播传媒 College)

Adding more exams to the syllabus should help in the long run, says Nina Tupper ’14 of Kennebunk, Maine. (Phyllis Graber Jensen/乐播传媒 College)

No more Monday quizzes

The weekly quizzes will be on Friday from now on, and they’ll be at the beginning of class, not the end.

Having the quiz on Monday meant students boned up on Sunday, when there’s not a lot of academic support if they get stuck.

Giving a quiz at the end of class is when students aren’t at their best. Their brains are jumbled, the day’s new information competing with what they need to recall for the quiz.

Thank God it鈥檚 (not) Friday

Having optional review sessions on a Friday afternoon was difficult for student who had already spent an hour and 20 minutes in a lecture. 鈥淚t鈥檚 hard to stay focused on statistics for three hours on a Friday afternoon,鈥 says Kelsey Berry. They’ll be on Wednesday afternoons now.

Unit of measurement

To give the course more of a real-world feel, Douglass and her students have organized the class into four units: Health Psychology, Social Psychology, Psychology and Law, and Parenting and Families.

鈥淲e had units before, but they were week-to-week and perhaps not as cohesive,” Douglass says. “They will allow students to explore their interests while applying statistical knowledge.鈥

Speak now

When a professor teaches new ideas and new content right up until the last day of the semester, students don鈥檛 always learn well. But they do stress out.

web-140515_Short_Term_Showcase_0359

Afifa Avril 鈥15 and Patrece Joseph 鈥14 talk at a campus event on May 15 where students from various Short Term courses made poster presentations. (Phyllis Graber Jensen/乐播传媒 College)

This winter, the statistics course will instead conclude with student presentations. 鈥淭hey鈥檒l analyze a dataset, and talk about what they鈥檝e learned,鈥 says Eleanor Hough.

鈥淧reparing an oral presentation makes a student think about the material in different ways,鈥 says Afifa Avril. 鈥淚t also doubles as a way for students to review material for the final鈥

Demo reports done differently

The course asks students to write demonstration reports in American Psychological Association style, meaning they needed four parts: Introduction, Methods, Results and Discussion.

In addition, they write two appendixes, one for hand calculations and one that explains statistical concepts to a lay audience.

鈥淲e decided to eliminate two writing-intensive parts of the reports, the Introduction and Discussion,鈥 Douglass says, 鈥渟o students can focus more on the conceptual content of an APA-style report.鈥

It’s a sensible move. Learning to write an APA-style Introduction and Discussion is already taught in two required methods courses, Psychology 261 (鈥淩esearch Methods鈥) and Psychology 262 (“Community-Based Research Methods”).

Pssst! SPSS Analyses!

Last year, students were required to do brief, outside-of-class analyses using a software known as
SPSS (Statistical Package for the Social Sciences).

Next year, students will do their stastical software analyses during class time, explains Margaret Foster. (Phyllis Graber Jensen/乐播传媒 College)

Next year, students will do their statistical software analyses during class time, explains Margaret Foster. (Phyllis Graber Jensen/乐播传媒 College)

Next year, students will do SPSS analyses in class. They’ll be harder, and will use student-designed worksheets. “Importantly, the worksheets will assume that students watched the videos about hand calculations,” says Douglass.

Meaning that when students come to class to do an SPSS analysis, they will (or should) be ready to roll.

“Moving the SPSS analyses into the class time will allow students to learn more about manipulating the numbers in a problem,” explains Foster.

“It’s like they’re paying it forward.”

Looking back on the experience with her students, Douglass says two things struck her: her students’ creative approaches to solving problems, and their abiding interest in making the course better for the next generation of students.

“Even though they’re done with it, they really care about making it better for the next cohort,” Douglass says. “It’s like they’re paying it forward.”